Renters’ Rights Act and the individual landlord: who really loses out?

Lucy Roberts, Lettings Director at Principle, on what the Renters' Rights Act really means for the individual landlord, and why the tenants it aims to protect could end up paying the price.

Lucy Roberts, FARLA, Lettings Director

There's been a lot of discussion, and a fair amount of anxiety, about what the long-term effects of the Renters' Rights Act will be. Many are asking the same question: is this yet another nail in the coffin for the individual landlord?

My team and I are privileged to manage properties on behalf of many excellent individual landlords. Some have trusted us for more than 20 years, relying on us to guide them through compliance, protect their bricks and mortar and ultimately ensure their tenants are well looked after.

These landlords do not resemble the caricature often portrayed in the media or by policymakers: the "big bad landlord", uncaring, greedy and exploitative.

In reality, I've seen the opposite:

  • Landlords who reduced rent during COVID

  • Landlords who wrote off arrears during difficult times

  • Landlords who genuinely care about their tenants' wellbeing

They understand that being a landlord is a two-way relationship. Look after your tenants and they will look after the property. Treat them with respect and they will treat the home as their own.

But these good landlords are being squeezed from every direction. The pressure on individual landlords is mounting and the list of challenges grows longer every year:

  • Increasing taxation

  • Selective licensing schemes

  • Minimum energy efficiency standards

  • Rising mortgage interest rates

  • A court system that is slow, outdated and not fit for purpose

The law exists to protect tenants, and rightly so. But somewhere along the way, we seem to have forgotten that good landlords also need protecting. Instead of incentivising responsible behaviour, we risk punishing the very people who are doing things properly.

And let's not forget the bigger picture. There is a significant shortfall in state housing. The government relies on private landlords to fill that gap. If we continue to push individual landlords out, who will step in?

Are individual landlords leaving the sector?

Unfortunately, yes. I'm already seeing it happen.

Some landlords feel the path has become too thorny: too much risk, too much regulation, too much fear of getting something wrong. Others have simply concluded that the return no longer justifies the effort and are selling up to release their pension pot early.

And who replaces them? Corporate landlords.

Will they be compliant? Absolutely. Will they tick every box? Without question.

Will they care about the tenant who has lived there for years, keeps the property immaculate, and relies on being close to the local school? Will they choose to keep the rent slightly lower because they value stability and loyalty? Let's be honest, probably not. To a corporate landlord, that tenant becomes a number on a spreadsheet. A calculation. A yield.

Renters' Rights Act, Section 13 and the reality of market rent

Some of our long-standing individual landlords now find themselves with rents far below market value. Some chose not to increase rents during COVID. Others held back during the cost-of-living crisis. Meanwhile, rents surged due to supply and demand.

A property that rented for £800 in early 2020 might have easily been worth £1,300 by 2023.

These landlords have tried to bridge the gap gradually, with small, staggered increases in line with RPI. However, even today, many remain significantly below market rent.

Under the Renters' Rights Act, they now have the legal mechanism to raise rents to full market value, provided they have strong comparable evidence and the First-tier Tribunal will have to honour it.

But here's the real risk.

If a landlord becomes disillusioned and decides to sell with the tenant in situ, the new owner will almost certainly want market rent immediately, or they may serve notice to enable a sale with vacant possession. Either way, the tenant, who may have been protected by a fair and compassionate landlord for years, suddenly finds themselves searching for a new home at a much higher market rent.

So who really loses out? We all know the answer.

We need balance, not blame

The Renters' Rights Act aims to protect tenants, and that is a worthy goal. But in the process, we risk destabilising the very foundation of the private rented sector: the individual, responsible landlord.

These landlords are not the problem. They are part of the solution.

If we continue to push them out, the sector will shift towards large corporate ownership. Compliant, yes, but far less personal, far less flexible and far less connected to the human realities of renting.

A healthy housing market needs balance. It needs good tenants and good landlords. It needs protection but also incentives. It needs regulation but also respect for those who do things right.

If we forget that, the people who will ultimately pay the price are not landlords, but the very tenants the legislation is designed to protect.

And what about us agents? The reality behind the role

It's not just landlords feeling the pressure. Agents and property managers are carrying an enormous load too.

The lettings industry is now one of the most heavily regulated sectors in the UK. In fact, there are around 140 Acts of Parliament and more than 400 individual regulations that impact the private rented sector in England. And no, please don't ask me to list them all.

Our property managers are highly skilled, deeply knowledgeable and constantly learning. They have to be. The rules change frequently, the expectations grow year on year and the paperwork has multiplied beyond recognition. What used to be a relatively straightforward role has evolved into a complex professional discipline requiring legal awareness, technical understanding, emotional intelligence and operational precision.

Every day, our team navigates a maze of responsibilities, including:

  • Marketing properties correctly and compliantly

  • Setting appropriate rent levels in a volatile market

  • Managing repairs and maintenance

  • Planning cyclical works and long-term improvements

  • Coordinating EPC upgrades and energy efficiency requirements

  • Chasing arrears sensitively but firmly

  • Conducting inspections and reporting accurately

  • Handling disputes and negotiations

  • Managing expectations on both sides, landlord and tenant

  • Ensuring every process, document and decision meets legal standards

And that's just the shortlist.

It's a role that demands balance, judgement and resilience. Property managers are the ones who absorb the stress, solve the problems and keep everything moving, often without recognition for the sheer volume of work happening behind the scenes.

For landlords who self-manage, this landscape can be overwhelming. For our property managers, it's daily life. So yes, kudos to our team.

They juggle all these responsibilities (and more) with professionalism, patience and a genuine commitment to doing things properly. They are the steady hands guiding landlords through complexity and ensuring tenants have safe, well-managed homes.

Next
Next

The hidden work of a managing agent: why great property management delivers more value than many leaseholders realise